|
|
Post by Techno-bot on Apr 19, 2005 22:05:47 GMT -5
Think long and hard, only one vote per customer, you know! If you think it's someone OTHER than the above, feel free to post as a 'guest' (so you can be anonymous) and add your vote for that 'other' person.
Only 8 spots, so Keith Mars and Abel Koonz were left out. We know neither of them did it, right?
THIS POLL WILL BE LOCKED AT 6 PM EASTERN ON TUESDAY, MAY 10. A FEW HOURS BEFORE THE FINAL EPISODE AIRS.
|
|
|
|
Post by ElleKC on Apr 21, 2005 13:40:54 GMT -5
I've believed since the Christmas episodes that the killer is Aaron Echolls. I'll admit that real-world considerations pointed me that direction. Harry Hamlin is too big of a 'name' to waste on a part-time character. However, storylines recently ('Hot Dogs' in particular) make it increasingly likely. Aaron has a temper and is violent. He is very concerned about his image as a star. If Lily Kane learned something that could ruin his career and expose him to the world, he might react violently. Say for example, Lily learned of his abuse of Logan and taunted him about it, he might lash out. If he struck her and she hit her head (as in the flashback of the 'Mrs Celeste as murderer'), she might have died of her injuries. Alternatively, Aaron might have been having sex with Lily. He is extraordinarily unfaithful, and probably wouldn't blink at sex with a teenage girl. She could have threatened to expose him for that. Lily didn't seem to have much self-control or common sense. She could have threatened him without meaning it and he reacted. Of course, that would mean the Lily was a verrrry busy girl. I think it is definate that Jake and Celeste Kane think that Duncan did it, thereby bribing Abel Koontz and covering up the murder. This alone leaves them out of the running. Duncan almost surely found the body. As long as I'm talking about Duncan, I'm sure he broke up with Veronica because his mother told him that Veronica could be his half-sister.  As for the whole roofies and rape subplot, I'm afraid that it will be found that Logan did have a hand in it. (Just for the record, I like Logan and V/L.) He blamed Veronica for breaking him and Lily up, which lead to him not being with her the night of the murder. I could see Logan of the pre-pilot wanting revenge, and drugging her drink an appropriate punishment. He is a teenager and they often make bad choices. Originally, I thought perhaps no rape was involved... Veronica just woke up without her underwear and couldn't be sure of what happened. From the posts I've read, I'm thinking now I was wrong, and perhaps she was assaulted while unconscious. Logan could have done it, but I would bet that his participation was limited to the drugging. I could see Logan wanting to punish her, but not actually being able to go through with it. If this is the case, much angst and guilt will ensue. No more V/L, not for a long time, at least. |
|
|
|
Post by ElleKC on Apr 21, 2005 13:43:42 GMT -5
Hey moderators,
I wasn't sure how to actually vote on this thing, so if I did it incorrectly, please remove the previous vote and let me know how!
|
|
|
|
Post by Techno-bot on Apr 21, 2005 22:42:59 GMT -5
Hey moderators, I wasn't sure how to actually vote on this thing, so if I did it incorrectly, please remove the previous vote and let me know how! you need to go to the POLL part of this and click the button by Aaron Echoll's name - that will register a vote for him. Then you can delete or leave your post. It wasn't necessary but it was interesting! |
|
|
|
Post by Sue on Apr 21, 2005 23:10:06 GMT -5
you need to go to the POLL part of this and click the button by Aaron Echoll's name - that will register a vote for him. Then you can delete or leave your post. It wasn't necessary but it was interesting! Patti, and Elle---I suspect that as a guest she doesn't show the voting buttons. What you likely need to do is officially register with the site, then you'll be allowed to actually "vote" in the poll itself. Not that we can't count your vote as it stands, but it won't show up in the poll numbers. |
|
|
|
Post by SpringSummers on Apr 22, 2005 7:46:07 GMT -5
Patti, and Elle---I suspect that as a guest she doesn't show the voting buttons. What you likely need to do is officially register with the site, then you'll be allowed to actually "vote" in the poll itself. Not that we can't count your vote as it stands, but it won't show up in the poll numbers. Yes - first - lemme say: Welcome Elle! We'd love to have your vote officially recorded - very interesting theory you've got there. To vote, you have to register - at the very top of the screen there is a "Log In or Register" option. Choose register. Once you are completely registered, you can log in and vote. Thanks for your interest and for adding your thoughts to the thread. Join us in the VM ep discussions, or any other thread that strikes your fancy. |
|
|
|
Post by Patti - S'cubie Cutie on Apr 24, 2005 11:55:03 GMT -5
Patti, and Elle---I suspect that as a guest she doesn't show the voting buttons. What you likely need to do is officially register with the site, then you'll be allowed to actually "vote" in the poll itself. Not that we can't count your vote as it stands, but it won't show up in the poll numbers. duh! of course! Only members can vote in the polls, I'd forgotten that! |
|
|
|
Post by Sue on May 9, 2005 18:44:46 GMT -5
Don't forget to vote in the poll.
I have to leave for a meeting around 5 tomorrow so I'll close the poll and open the discussion thread sometime BEFORE 6 PM eastern. So don't leave it until the last minute.
|
|
As for the whole roofies and rape subplot, I'm afraid that it will be found that Logan did have a hand in it. (Just for the record, I like Logan and V/L.) He blamed Veronica for breaking him and Lily up, which lead to him not being with her the night of the murder. I could see Logan of the pre-pilot wanting revenge, and drugging her drink an appropriate punishment. He is a teenager and they often make bad choices. 
